Skip Navigation LinksBlog

DC Insider: Federal agency expands authority from fighting diseases to studying how Americans use our highways


Go Back

Alongside the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, there is a relatively new player looking at motorcycle safety on our roads and highways.

It is the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Why the CDC? How is riding a motorcycle even in the CDC’s crosshairs? Is the CDC attempting to say that riding is a disease?

How is this possible? What is the CDC’s agenda?

The American Motorcyclist Association is asking these questions and may have found some answers.

The CDC came onto the AMA radar back in June 2012 with its release claiming that annual cost savings in states with universal motorcycle helmet laws were nearly four times greater (per registered motorcycle) than in states without universal helmet laws. It is no secret that the CDC wants more states to adopt mandatory helmet laws.

Then, it was the CDC’s February 2013 Federal Register notice on its proposed project titled “Costs and Cost Savings of Motor Vehicle Injury Prevention: Evidence-Based Policy and Behavioral Interventions.”

The AMA wanted the CDC to address our concerns with the proposed project’s goal to “collect information relating to the costs of implementing motor vehicle injury prevention interventions” to get— in their own words -- the “biggest bang for the buck.”

We learned that the CDC study would focus on 13 “interventions.” One is “motorcycle helmet use laws.”

Then the CDC struck again.

At its meeting in October 2013, the Community Preventive Services Task Force viewed a CDC staff-prepared presentation about the benefits of universal helmet laws. One of the slides links the adoption of universal helmet-use laws to a potential reduction in motorcycle riding, which would help meet the CDC’s goal to reduce injuries and fatalities.

Let me say that again: One of the CDC’s desired outcomes is the potential for reduced motorcycle use. (The task force had previously approved a recommendation for universal motorcycle helmet laws at its meeting in June 2013.)

The AMA questions the expertise and authority of the CDC and its task force in the traffic safety arena. Motorcycling is not a disease to be cured; it is a legal and legitimate means of transportation and recreation enjoyed by an estimated 11 million Americans.

U.S. Rep. Tim Walberg (R-Mich.) shared the AMA’s concern and sent a letter to the CDC on Nov. 21, 2013. In particular, Walberg wanted to know how the CDC has the authority to study highway safety.

The CDC responded by saying its authority is congressionally mandated.

Congressionally mandated?

This stimulated  investigative juices at the AMA. After months of research, the AMA discovered that the CDC’s authority comes from Section 399U of the Public Health Service Act. This is odd, because the PHS Act has been around for years.

Is Section 399U new and how did it amend the PHS Act?

Yes, the section is new. It was included in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as Obamacare. It increased the CDC’s authority and gave it a congressional mandate to study highway safety, among other things. Specifically, Section 4003(b)(1) of the ACA amended the PHS Act to include Section 399U.

How does Section 399U expand the authority of the CDC’s Task Force?

It expands the role of the Community Preventive Services Task Force by “… providing yearly reports to Congress and related agencies identifying gaps in research and recommending priority areas that deserve further examination, including areas related to populations and age groups not adequately addressed by current recommendations” (ACA, § 4003(b)(1); PHS Act § 399U(b)(6)) (ACA pages 425-426).

It also provides authority to the task force to study any area or topic it chooses. Under Section 399U, “Community preventive services include any policies, programs, processes or activities designed to affect or otherwise affecting health at the population level” (Emphasis added) (ACA, § 4003(b)(1); PHS Act § 399U(a) (ACA pages 425-426).

Although we can’t all agree on the validity of mandated helmet laws, I am sure we all can agree that this is blatant government overreach that can affect all our lives by administrative fiat.

This is how a federal agency once tasked to curing the world’s diseases is now studying our nation’s highways – and, for that matter, anything else it chooses.

    Facebook Twitter DZone It! Digg It! StumbleUpon Technorati Del.icio.us NewsVine Reddit Blinklist Add diigo bookmark

Comments  33

  • Timothy I McMillen 01 May

    I want this government out of my life.  They way things are going we will be charged for passing gas because it is methane; a green house gas.  With that said.
    I will address my own safety.
    I do NOT need or want the government dictating to me how I should protect myself in any aspect of my life.
    The helmet is just the first step, I am sure.
    I am sure the mandated helmet law will then dictate the kind of helmet; full face no doubt, DOT & Snell.
    Next it will be mandated that you have to wear a certain kind of boot.
    Then it will be the kind of  jacket you wear, leather or textile, armored?
    Then the type of gloves will be next.
    And why stop there?
    They can look at where accidents are most likely occur and ban motorcycles from those areas.
    Once the government get a start, there is no end to it.
  • muberry bayswater bag size Balenciaga by oh 19 Jul

    Wholesale Handba muberry bayswater bag size gs Technological and societal changes have been a muberry bayswater bag uk great influence in the handbag's history. The development of the transportation system has increased people's mobility and with this occurrence, professional luggage makers have to muberry bayswater bag size
  • Wholesale Mulberry Bayswater Bags by mw 19 Jul

    Chanel clothing Coco Chanel founder of the Wholesale Mulberry Bayswater Bags Chanel fashion house is a Cheap Mulberry Bayswater Bags Parisian based fashion industry. Gabrielle Chanel started with a small shop in Paris, in 1909, when she never ever had imagined this was a little door for her enormous success a Wholesale Mulberry Bayswater Bags w
  • muberry clutch bag gumtree by xb 19 Jul

    Food Network Jane muberry clutch bag fake t Johnston,muberry clutch bag fake, passionate Denver-based spice-sho muberry clutch bag gumtree p owner and avid home cook, promises minimum fuss and maximum flavor in her new "In the Kitchen" Food Network cooking series,muberry clutch bag gumtree, Spice E muberry clutch bag fake a
  • fake muberry bayswater bag 相关的主题文章 by nu 20 Jul

    fashion handbags are big business muberry bayswater bag grey The still red-hot status handbag market d fake muberry bayswater bag riven by celebrity trendsetters such as Katie Holmes and Victoria Beckham has not escaped the notice of some big auction houses. They say it's a new and growing category t black muberry bayswater bag h
  • muberry clutch bag tan by cj 20 Jul

    Loss of Rs100 note causes four deaths in Uttar Pradesh muberry clutch bag daria village,muberry clutch bag daria Mukesh died next of suffocation as he jump muberry clutch bag tan ed into the tank to save his son. Two villagers who dived into the pit to pull out the father and son met the same f muberry clutch bag john lewis a
  • muberry clutch bag daria --"Facebook Haiti by tw 20 Jul

    The 2nd Ghetto Biennale and Other Pleasant News From Haiti In writi muberry clutch bag daria ng of the Sculptors of muberry clutch bag daria the Grand Rue,muberry clutch bag daria, an artist collective,muberry clutch bag daria, which partnered with British photographer Leah Gordon to orchestrate muberry clutch bag tan t
  • Mulberry Clutch Bags Sale by wf 22 Jul

    Gilad Atzmon's latest masterpiece Controlling the Opposition. Footbal Mulberry Clutch Bags Sale l Time Monk Radio: Exposing The Jewish Shtick (many new ideas) The Mulberry Clutch Bags Outlet Jewish Bank that Rules The World ! (must watch) Rinaldo Francesca: Israel is back at the UN Human Rights Counc Wholesale Mulberry Clutch Bags i
  • Hermes Kelly Bags sizes by ur 24 Jul

    but where's the back half Hermes,Hermes Kelly Bags sizes, best known for Hermes Kelly Bags sizes it's £3,000 Birkin Hermes Kelly Bags online handbags and silk scarves, is branching out into another luxury line. revolutionary yachts. The stylish French company has teamed up with the Monaco-ba Hermes Kelly Bags for sale s
  • Hermes Kelly Bags Sale preference by yr 24 Jul

    Genuine Designer label Handbags Do They Retain Their Value So Wholesale Hermes Kelly Bags me h Wholesale Hermes Kelly Bags andle bags being a prized possession at the same time other deal with it as plain need as most ladies cannot go out not having carrying things. Other people deal with them being an Hermes Kelly Bags Outlet a
  • Hermes Kelly Bags Sale Destroyed by hy 24 Jul

    Francesca Eastwood receive death threats after sh Hermes Kelly Bags Discount e and her boyfriend Tyler Shields set fire to a,Hermes Kelly Bags Dis Hermes Kelly Bags Discount count 'Wow. The $100k wasted on this pointless shoot could of been used to benefit a number of charities or ppl in real need. Ju Wholesale Hermes Kelly Bags s
  • Hermes Kelly Bags color by ye 29 Jul

    World Rings In 2012 And Bids Adieu To A Tough Year NE Hermes Kelly Bags color W YORK (AP) - With glittering fireworks an Hermes Kelly Bags Cheap d star-studded celebrations from New Zealand to Times Square, the world eagerly welcomed a new year and hoped for a better future Saturday, saying good Hermes Kelly Bags Discount b
  • Hermes Birkin bags Discount Exclusive Status by by 30 Jul

    Excl Hermes Birkin bags Discount usive Status, Hermes Birkin bags Sale Hermes Birkin bags Discount The Louis Vuitton Tribute Patchwork is this summer's ultimate status bag,Hermes Birkin bags Sale, ringing in at Hermes Birkin bags Cheap $52,500. And it is arriving in Washington by the end of the season, ordered by a woman who
  • mullberry bags sale outlet JAMIE CARRAGHER by sq 02 Aug

    'New Vieira' Diaby deli mullberry bags sale outlet vers a blast from the past as Ars red muberry bayswater bag enal march on,mullberry bags sale outlet,red muberry bayswater bag 'I thought he played extremely well in the second half against Newcastle,mullberry bags sale review. He has power coming up mullberry bags sale review
  • Yves Saint Laurent wallets by dz 04 Aug

    The new Romeo of romance Abundance. Probably THE word that best Yves Saint Laurent wallets describes life in Yves Saint Laurent wallets the (or whatever you want to call it). We so spoilt for choice as consumers that our longing for possessions is flooding us like the Atlantic Ocean engulfing the Ti Yves Saint Laurent wallets t
  • ysl bags blush to help a few years later. by ke 04 Aug

    Owned Chevy Chase Boutique Saks Jandel Mr. Marx's store in Chevy Chase starte ysl bags blush d as a fur shop that he later expanded into a high-end fashion destination. H Yves Saint Laurent cluth bags price e was one of the first to import modern European ready-to-wear clothing to the United States Yves Saint Laurent cluth bags
  • Hermes Birkin bags for cheap hogan donna by sx 12 Aug

    hogan donna,Hermes Kelly Bags 2014,Artikelen Zoeken Vind Hier De Meest Hermes Kelly Bags 2014 Popuburrowe Artikelen Welcome to discover hogan hemers factory outlet donna .Our website design is dedicated and providing the latest erina kors manufacturing area avenue goodies with good high quali Hermes Birkin bags for cheap t
  • Vivienne Westwood Jewellery cheap herbology by yd 02 Sep

    Role Of Herbali Vivienne Westwood Jewellery cheap st,Vivienne Westwood Jewel Vivienne Westwood Jewellery shop lery cheap Education of herbalists differs in various areas of the globe,Vivienne Westwood Jewellery shop. Mostly herbalists and traditional medicine user rely upon apprenticeship and reco Vivienne Westwood Earrings price gnition from the c
  • Vivienne Westwood Melissa 2 by oz 02 Sep

    Sreeja N Vivienne Westwood Melissa ag answer to What do IITs lack which universities l Vivienne Westwood Melissa heels ike MIT I've been to at least one of the institutions on both sides of the comparison (undergrad at an IIT, grad school at MIT), so I'll take a stab at answering: 1) Students studyi Vivienne Westwood Melissa heart shoes ng s
  • Vivienne Westwood Earrings stockists by ur 02 Sep

    High School Musical,Vivienne Westwood Vivienne Westwood Earrings stockists Earrings stock Vivienne Westwood Clothes punk ists,Vivienne Westwood Clothes punk He does comedy, writes books,cheap Vivienne Westwood Clothes,Vivienne Westwood Clothes for heroes, mixes it up with the hottest stars in music and Hollywood. cheap Vivienne Westwood Clothes W
  • Hollister Clearance vivienne westwood 12 Sep

    vivienne westwood, What exactly must going to Hollister Clearance be the par Canada Goose Danmak tners bring that will accelerate the availability about indexed records?and to When going to be the partner creates the index,Hollister Clearance, FamilySearch allows as well as for a short tim Canada Goose Jakke e
  • Abercrombie And Fitch Outlet 12 Sep

    .The some other way for mo Abercrombie And Fitch Outlet re info Hollister Outlet rmation about gain access at this point is the reason that to explore opt-in to educate yourself regarding going to be the partner basic services Is this fair for more information about volunt Abercrombie Outlet eers which of you fat t n
  • Abercrombie Kids Outelt 13 Sep

    ..abercrombie and fi abercrombie and fitch outlet tch outlet,Abercrombie Kids Outelt,Following my own personal previously Abercrombie Kids Outelt posted Cheon Song Yi’s make all the way several breakdown and YSL lippieobssession, this the span of time I’ll tell you about your son or daughter drool dese Hollister Clearance r
  • Vivienne Westwood Bracelet mens 相关的主题文章 by gv 13 Sep

    Tristan Irwin answer to In layman terms,Vivi Vivienne Westwood Orb Earrings gold enne Westwood Orb Earrings gold In la Vivienne Westwood Bracelet mens yman terms,Vivienne Westwood Bracelet mens,Vivienne Westwood Orb Earrings ebay,Vivienne Westwood Orb Earrings fake, an API is an agreement between two people stating Vivienne Westwood Orb Earrings ebay :
  • Vivienne Westwood Jewellery sale by fr 13 Sep

    Attraction Market Vivienne Westwood Jewellery sale ing Secrets When peop Vivienne Westwood Jewellery cheap le join a network marketing company, they focus on the networking aspect of the business but ignore the Marketing part. Most people do not know how to Vivienne Westwood Jewellery meadowhall market and they attempt to build their business and then t
  • Vivienne Westwood shirts cheap by mi 13 Sep

    com Guestbook,Vivienne Westwood sh Vivienne Westwood shirts cheap irts cheap entraron kon el floro del kambio Vivienne Westwood shirts ??? k no iva haber lucro y tampoco portasos y iva haber mas viajes y fiezta y k kada barrio iva chapar sus entradaz k le corresponde ,Vivienne Westwood shirts???? pero Vivienne Westwood Ring s
  • Vivienne Westwood Clothes punk by rk 14 Sep

    Canuck Place in Abbotsford nears fundraising goal,Vivienne Westwood Clot Vivienne Westwood Clothes punk hes punk,Vivienne Westwood Clothes for heroes Canuck Place Children's Hos Vivienne Westwood Clothes for heroes pice in Abbotsford is about $1 million away from reaching the $13 million goal for its capital campai Vivienne Westwood Earrings gold g
  • Vivienne Westwood Bags usa expectations by ik 14 Sep

    Fo Vivienne Westwood Boots pirate cus on th Vivienne Westwood Bags usa e Customer Have you ever tried to offer help to a friend or relative only to be told,Vivienne Westwood Boots pirate, "But you don't understand!" Selling products and services Vivienne Westwood Boots melissa to customers isn't much different than offering advice to
  • Abercrombie Outlet 14 Sep

    .abercrombie children outelt, February 4, 2014, FamilySear Abercrombie Outlet ch announced a series relating to Hollister Outlet agreements to have AncestryMore volunteers are at all times needed, especially any of those with facts all over the languages all the other than EnglishOur c Hollister Clearance a
  • Vivienne Westwood Roman Shoes or training by yf 14 Sep

    Do You Have a Busine Vivienne Westwood Roman Shoes ss Mindse Vivienne Westwood Purses ebay t 1. Having a business mindset is knowing that the purpose of business is to make money. Sometimes your hobby is just a hobby. Either you're going to have a hobby tha Vivienne Westwood black Orb Earrings t makes you a little extra money or you're going to
  • Vivienne Westwood Wallet sale by ed 15 Sep

    Top 7 Ergonomic Office Chair Mechanisms to have in the Wo Vivienne Westwood Wallet sale rkspace Seat Height Adjustability: This function allows Vivienne Westwood Sunglasses 2014 the user to adjust the height of the chair to allow one's feet to rest comfortably on the floor or footstool while still maintaining Vivienne Westwood Pirate Boots o
  • Vivienne Westwood Pirate Boots ebay by lc 15 Sep

    How to Strengthen Your Wrists,Vivienne Westwood Pirate Boots Vivienne Westwood Pirate Boots ebay ebay Vivienne Westwood Wallet mens ,Vivienne Westwood Wallet mens Do various weight exercises to strengthen your wrists: Wrist Curls- Take a dumbbell and hold it so your palm faces upwards with your arm perpendicu Vivienne Westwood Pirate Boots price l
  • Hollister Outlet On February 4 15 Sep

    On February 4, 2014, FamilySearch announced a multi function telev Hollister Outlet ision shows of agreements with AncestryMore volun Abercrombie And Fitch Outlet teers are all of the time needed, especially those to have wisdom all over the languages other than EnglishOur hope is that a number o Abercrombie Kids Outelt f
Post a comment!
  1. Formatting options